Levels of evidence
Not all evidence is equal. Each fact we collect has a level from 1 to 5, by how hard it is to fake. Level 5 is the hardest, level 1 the easiest. The questions behind the score give much more weight to the higher levels.
Level 5: one fact
Evidence that is impossible to fake: an independent authority checks who the organisation is before granting it, and grants it to no one else.
- Domain ending only a vetted kind of organisation can hold
Level 4: eight facts
Evidence that cannot realistically be created quickly because it requires genuine elapsed time or a long independent historical record.
- Company age
- Domain age
- Founding year and place as the encyclopaedia states it
- Headcount as the encyclopaedia states it, with its year
- Independent review platform rating
- Revenue as the encyclopaedia states it, with its year
- Website archive history
- Wikipedia page about the company
Level 3: ten facts
Evidence that is difficult or expensive to fabricate at meaningful scale, such as substantial accumulated customer activity, sustained traffic or authentic large audiences.
- Accounts overdue
- Confirmation statement overdue
- Filing history consistent
- Independent review platform review count
- Independent review platforms
- Insolvency history
- Known data breaches found
- Parent company
- Registered office in dispute
- Social follower counts
Level 2: thirteen facts
Independent and useful evidence, but relatively accessible to both legitimate and fraudulent businesses.
- Business email at its own domain, confirmed by Truth Signal
- Company found in official company register
- Company status
- Company status detail
- Contact phone number found
- ICO data-protection fee payer
- Malware or phishing threat status
- Registered address
- Registered company name
- Security certificate browsers warn about
- Social platforms with discovered profiles
- Sources agreeing on postcode
- Whether registered company activity matches the website
Level 1: twenty facts
Evidence that can be created cheaply or almost instantly and therefore provides only weak positive evidence.
- Contact email or contact form available
- Contact page found
- DKIM key
- DMARC policy
- DMARC record
- Domain transfer lock enabled
- Facebook page
- HTTPS enabled
- Instagram page
- LinkedIn page
- MX records
- Privacy page found
- Returns page found
- SPF record
- Shipping page found
- Terms page found
- TikTok page
- X page
- YouTube channel
- YouTube page