# Midtown Comics (midtowncomics.com)

Is midtowncomics.com legit and trustworthy? Truth score 75 out of 100, high truth signals: 6 of 11 public checks clear, 1 to be cautious about, 1 not found, 3 for information. Legitimacy confidence: high. Customer satisfaction: mostly dissatisfied.

- Truth score: 75 out of 100
- Legitimacy confidence: high
- Customer satisfaction: mostly dissatisfied, from Trustpilot · 19 reviews · rating not read; SmartCustomer 2.1 · 32 reviews; Reviews.io 1.0 · 1 reviews; App Store 5.0 · 5 ratings
- Claimed: no
- Assessed: 2026-10-26

## Business details

- Founded: 1997
- Sells: Physical goods
- Sells to: The public
- Kind of seller: Sells its own goods or services
- Licensed trade: No licence normally needed
- Domain age: 28 years
- Address: 1403 Fourth Avenue, New Hyde Park, NY 11040
- Email address: info@midtowncomics.com
- Phone number: +1 800-411-3341
- Contact page: https://midtowncomics.com/contact-us/
- Website: https://midtowncomics.com/
- Social media: Facebook https://facebook.com/midtowncomics, Instagram https://instagram.com/midtowncomics, X https://twitter.com/midtowncomics, YouTube https://www.youtube.com/user/midtowncomicstv
- Latest YouTube video: Spectacular Spider-Man Brand New Day #1 Signing with Dan Slott Live from Grand Central! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YTjV5KIgBX8

## Summary

We read 5 of its pages: contact, about, delivery, terms and privacy. Its website address was registered 28 years ago, and is locked against transfer to someone else. No malware or phishing warnings found for its website. Be cautious: its 32 reviews on SmartCustomer average only 2.1 stars out of 5. Its 1 reviews on Reviews.io average only 1.0 stars out of 5. We could not find social media profiles.

Important context: Truth Signal weighs public evidence about this business. A high score means strong evidence that the business is established and legitimate, not a promise that it is safe to buy from or that every purchase will go well. A low score means the evidence is thin or raises concerns, not that the business is unsafe or a scam.

## Positives

- We read 5 of its pages: contact, about, delivery, terms and privacy (source: website)
- Its website address was registered 28 years ago (source: rdap)
- No malware or phishing warnings found for its website (source: safe_browsing)

## Be cautious

- A low number of independent reviews (32 on SmartCustomer), but it falls short with only 2.1 stars out of 5 (source: reviews)
- A low number of independent reviews (1 on Reviews.io), but it falls short with only 1.0 stars out of 5 (source: reviews)

## Not found

- Social presence information was not found from our checks. (source: social)

## How to check if midtowncomics.com is legit

To check if midtowncomics.com is legit yourself, look at the same public records we did: the company register, who owns the web address and since when, customer reviews, visitor numbers, how long the site has existed, social profiles, malware lists, data breaches and email security. Each row below shows what that record says about midtowncomics.com; open a row to see the facts and the source to check them yourself. Step by step: [how to know if a shopping site is legit](/guides/how-to-know-if-a-shopping-site-is-legit).

- Who they are: Company details: Based in the US; serves the US; founded in 1997 (Wikipedia) (For information)
- Who they are: Domain registration: Its website address was registered 28 years ago (Clear)
- Who they are: Website details: We read 5 of its pages: contact, about, delivery, terms and privacy (Clear). Pages found: contact (https://midtowncomics.com/contact-us/), about (https://midtowncomics.com/about-us/), delivery (https://midtowncomics.com/shipping-info/), terms (https://midtowncomics.com/terms-of-use/), privacy (https://midtowncomics.com/privacy-policy/)
- Reputation and track record: Customer reviews: 51 reviews across 2 platforms, rated 2.1 to 2.1 out of 5 (Be cautious)
- Reputation and track record: App Store: Its app, Midtown Comics, is on Apple's App Store, rated 5 out of 5 from 5 ratings, counted in the reviews total. (For information)
- Reputation and track record: Visitor traffic: Real people visited its website in 24 of the last 24 months (For information)
- Reputation and track record: Web history and authority: Found: wikipedia page (Clear)
- Reputation and track record: Social presence: Its website links to its profiles on Facebook, Instagram, X and YouTube (Not found)
- Safety: Malware and phishing: No malware or phishing warnings found for its website (Clear). This check is not perfect: it can miss a harmful site, and it can wrongly warn about a safe one.
- Safety: Data breach history: No known data breach involving the company (Clear)
- Safety: Domain and email security: Its email is protected: mail forged in its name is blocked (Clear)

## What its pages say

Quoted word for word from midtowncomics.com's own pages.

- Ways to contact them: “If you're interested in selling your Comic Book collections, Toys, Collectibles, please visit our We Buy Comics page for more info or contact us through: → Email: webuy@midtowncomics.com → Tel: 646.452.8173 → VISIT US IN NEW YORK CITY!” (https://midtowncomics.com/contact-us/)
- In their own words: “The greatest characters and teams of all time are here too, including Batman, The New Avengers, Superman, Fantastic Four, Wonder Woman, Supergirl, Spider-Man, Spider-Verse, The Avengers, The Thunderbolts, Flash, Captain America, X-Men, Green Lantern, Wolverine, Black Widow, Thor, Daredevil, Dr. Midtown Comics is the go-to place for the best comic book Pull List (subscription service) to Marvel Comics, DC Comics, and all publishers. Shop online: Midtown Comics is committed to providing great service and prices and making the shopping experience as much fun as reading and collecting.” (https://midtowncomics.com/about-us/)
- Delivery cost: “Free Shipping on Qualifying Orders!” (https://midtowncomics.com/shipping-info/)

## Could not be checked this time

- social

## Cite

Truth Signal, Midtown Comics: truth score 75 out of 100, legitimacy confidence High, assessed 2026-10-26, https://truthsignal.com/business/midtowncomics.com. Licence CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). The same report as JSON: send Accept: application/json to https://truthsignal.com/business/midtowncomics.com