# The Catholic Company (catholiccompany.com)

Is catholiccompany.com legit and trustworthy? Truth score 90 out of 100, high truth signals: 7 of 10 public checks clear, 1 not found, 2 for information. Legitimacy confidence: high. Customer satisfaction: mostly satisfied.

- Truth score: 90 out of 100
- Legitimacy confidence: high
- Customer satisfaction: mostly satisfied, from Trustpilot 4 · 22,667 reviews; average 4.0
- Claimed: no
- Assessed: 2026-10-27

## Business details

- Founded by: James Hetzel, Whitney Hetzel
- Sells: Physical goods
- Sells to: The public
- Kind of seller: Sells its own goods or services
- Licensed trade: No licence normally needed
- Domain age: 25 years
- Address: 615 E. Westinghouse Blvd, Charlotte
- Email address: yourfriends@catholiccompany.com
- Phone number: +1 866-522-8465
- Contact page: https://catholiccompany.com/pages/contact-us
- Website: https://catholiccompany.com/
- Social media: Facebook https://www.facebook.com/catholiccompany, Instagram https://www.instagram.com/catholiccompany, TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/@CatholicCompany, YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@CatholicCompany
- Latest YouTube video: Product Personalization | Catholic Company https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EMv4Jh5IDos

## Summary

We read 4 of its pages: contact, about, returns and delivery. Its website address was registered 25 years ago. It is on 4 social media platforms (Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube), with its largest audience of 206,000 followers on Instagram. Customers have left 22,667 reviews on Trustpilot, averaging 4.0 stars out of 5. No malware or phishing warnings found for its website. We could not find an archive history for its website.

Important context: Truth Signal weighs public evidence about this business. A high score means strong evidence that the business is established and legitimate, not a promise that it is safe to buy from or that every purchase will go well. A low score means the evidence is thin or raises concerns, not that the business is unsafe or a scam.

Final check: privacy, terms pages linked: the site's own pages name them in a link or heading, but no such page was read.

## Positives

- We read 4 of its pages: contact, about, returns and delivery (source: website)
- Its website address was registered 25 years ago (source: rdap)
- It is on 4 social media platforms (Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube); the largest audience is 206,000 followers on Instagram (source: social)
- Excellent independent reputation: 22,667 reviews on Trustpilot, rated 4.0 stars out of 5 (source: reviews)
- No malware or phishing warnings found for its website (source: safe_browsing)

## Not found

- Web history and authority information was not found from our checks. (source: wayback)

## How to check if catholiccompany.com is legit

To check if catholiccompany.com is legit yourself, look at the same public records we did: the company register, who owns the web address and since when, customer reviews, visitor numbers, how long the site has existed, social profiles, malware lists, data breaches and email security. Each row below shows what that record says about catholiccompany.com; open a row to see the facts and the source to check them yourself. Step by step: [how to know if a shopping site is legit](/guides/how-to-know-if-a-shopping-site-is-legit).

- Who they are: Company details: Based in the US; serves Canada and the US (For information)
- Who they are: Domain registration: Its website address was registered 25 years ago (Clear)
- Who they are: Website details: We read 4 of its pages: contact, about, returns and delivery (Clear). Pages found: contact (https://catholiccompany.com/pages/contact-us), about (https://catholiccompany.com/pages/about-us), returns (https://catholiccompany.com/pages/returns-exchanges), delivery (https://catholiccompany.com/pages/shipping)
- Reputation and track record: Customer reviews: Rated 4.0 stars out of 5 from 22,667 reviews on Trustpilot (Clear)
- Reputation and track record: Visitor traffic: Real people visited its website in 24 of the last 24 months (For information)
- Reputation and track record: Web history and authority: nothing known (Not found)
- Reputation and track record: Social presence: It is on 4 social media platforms (Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube); the largest audience is 206,000 followers on Instagram (Clear)
- Safety: Malware and phishing: No malware or phishing warnings found for its website (Clear). This check is not perfect: it can miss a harmful site, and it can wrongly warn about a safe one.
- Safety: Data breach history: No known data breach involving the company (Clear)
- Safety: Domain and email security: Its email is protected: mail forged in its name goes to spam (Clear)

## What its pages say

Quoted word for word from catholiccompany.com's own pages.

- In their own words: “"Filling Our Father's House" by Shaun McAfee offers vibrant and simple strategies for reinvigorating Catholic evangelization. Drawing from his experience as a convert from Evangelical Protestantism, McAfee shares effective methods to make parish visitors feel welcome, integrate Scripture into daily life, and combat secularism. This inspiring guide aims to energize Catholics and enhance spiritual enrichment for engaging modern society.” (https://www.catholiccompany.com/products/filling-our-fathers-house-what-converts-can-teach-us-about-evangelization)
- How long you have to return: “Return Window: Items can be returned within 30 days of purchase.” (https://www.catholiccompany.com/pages/returns-exchanges)
- Faulty or damaged items: “To return defective or damaged products, please contact our Customer Experience team within 10 days of the delivery of your product.” (https://www.catholiccompany.com/pages/returns-exchanges)
- Delivery cost: “Important: The cost associated with Guardian Angel Protection is not applicable towards the minimum purchase requirement for free shipping promotions.” (https://www.catholiccompany.com/pages/shipping)

## Cite

Truth Signal, The Catholic Company: truth score 90 out of 100, legitimacy confidence High, assessed 2026-10-27, https://truthsignal.com/business/catholiccompany.com. Licence CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). The same report as JSON: send Accept: application/json to https://truthsignal.com/business/catholiccompany.com